|
| Latest Web News |
Doc Searls Produces Conference Wrapup
The close of the Syndicate Conference in New York came with Searls' keynote address, where he touched on the issue of "The Return to Producerism."
Amanda Congdon Talks Syndicating Videoblogs At Syndicate NY
Video blogs shouldn't be called "Internet TV"; Congdon said that completely devalues them. "They are a totally unique video experience, usually more casual."
Yahoo! Finance Badges Detailed
Another component in Yahoo's syndication strategy will enable publishers to embed financial information into their sites and blogs. Mani Kulasooriya from Yahoo said the toughest part of creating Yahoo! Finance Badges was not the technical side.
Google Notebook Goes Live
As promised at Google's Press Day event last week, its Notebook service from Google Labs has been turned on in beta for users to try. Firefox users will have an easy time of adding...
Justice Unworried About IE7 Search
Google had complained to US and European antitrust regulators about Microsoft including a search box with MSN Search as the default in Internet Explorer 7, but the Department of Justice had no problems with the feature.
Microsoft Targeting Google, Maybe
Frequent media stories that aim at pushing Microsoft and Google into an all-out battle royale don't really hit the mark according to Microsoft's CEO.
Can The FCC Save Net Neutrality?
The chief complaints of the telecommunications industry regarding the heated Network Neutrality debate are that regulation limits their ability to compete...
Schmidt: Google Has Just Begun
Google's CEO Eric Schmidt told media attendees at Press Day that search is the inevitable outcome of what is and will happen on the Internet.
Google Fills California Tax Coffers
All of that insider selling by Google insiders like Eric Schmidt, Larry Page, and Sergey Brin helped boost the state's take in personal income tax.
Microsoft Mapping The Real-Time World
Google may want to organize the world's information, but Microsoft wants to let you know how long you're going to have to wait for a table at Red Lobster on Friday evening.
Windows Live Messenger Offers VoIP
Microsoft will partner with Verizon to deliver PC to phone calling services as part of Live Messenger's new features being made available in the public beta release.
Google Threatens Wireless Market
A mixture of free wireless broadband connections and voice over Internet protocol applications will leave the mobile network market in the United States a smoldering unmourned wreck consigned to the scrapheap, but only in major cities.
Ballmer Emphasizes RSS Importance
Internet Explorer 7 and the Windows Vista operating system will support RSS, and Microsoft CEO Steve Ballmer thinks RSS feeds will grow in importance to Internet users.
Microsoft May Delay Vista Again
A two-sentence post from research firm Gartner has caused some uproar in the technology world, as Gartner researchers claim Microsoft will miss its release of Vista by three months, pushing it back into 2007.
Amazing Race Feeds Into E-Commerce
Reality show contestants don't vanish into fictional poofs at the show's conclusion. They're not the cast of Friends; there is life after the show. Chip Arndt, half of the winning duo of Amazing Race 4, left reality stardom to set up Merchant Advantage, an e-commerce company small businesses need to know about.
|
|
| Recent
Articles |
Integrating SEO With Public Relations
Karen Sams over at our PR firm, Misukanis & Odden does a nice job explaining the value and benefits of incorporating search engine optimization with public relations in a short PR and SEO video case study.
Do You Want To Be Just An Average SEO?
As a marketer, I'm fascinated by television commercials. One commercial I saw recently talked about how no one grows up wanting to be "average." That really shoved the right side of my brain into overdrive.
Search Engine Optimization: Beyond Search Keywords
The words people type into a search box are not always the words they like to read when they click on the search result. Here's why.
SEO For Google
This article is part three of a four part series on optimizing your website for the the three major search engines.
SEO For Non-profit Organization Blogs
Blogs are an SEO powerhouse for a non-profit organization and its various programs and events.
Undesirable SEO And What To Do With A Small Marketing Budget
I got a lead through our website the other day with an interesting comment attached. The prospect was requesting specific information on pricing for our services but as you can read below, they simply copied the information from what another SEO provided them.
Does Traditional SEO Still Work?
I had the pleasure of dining with my good friend, Mike Grehan, just before Easter. We chatted about the topic of his upcoming article - Does Textbook SEO Really Work Anymore?
NYT Discovers SEO
A story that ran in last Sunday's New York Times shows that the world of mainstream journalism is finally waking up to the importance of SEO.
Long Weekend And No SEO
I leave in an hour with the clan to California for a nice long weekend. Being a glutton for work, I will have my laptop with me so my post title is probably not entirely true.
Google Sitemaps Wants Your URLs
Vanessa Fox, a technical writer for Google's Sitemaps product, thinks you should be using Sitemaps with your site today. Here's why.
What We Want And What We Get!
If you have been using computers and the Internet for a while, you have probably figured out what works and what doesn't when it comes to searching for the things you want.
Google Plays Mythbusters With AdSense
Site publishers with questions about how CPC and CPM advertising work will benefit from Google's clarifications on the two ad formats.
Matt Cutts On Bigdaddy, RK, And Emmy
The Google engineer who webmasters have learned to love and fear tackled a slew of questions posted to his blog recently. There are only four or five live Matt Cutts sightings in a given year...
|
|
|
05.18.06
Walking In The Search Engines’ Shoes
 By
Robin Nobles
You know the old saying about not criticizing someone until you walk in their shoes.
But have you noticed how critical many SEOs and Webmasters are when it comes to the search engines, when they've never walked "in their shoes"? Spam is a perfect example.
The search engines have publicly stated that over 90% of submissions made through free add URL pages are spam. A few years ago, a FAST search engine representative showed me some examples of spam how they tracked spammers, the sheer amount of spam coming from just one spammer, and so forth. Can you imagine how much better their strategies are now for catching spammers?
It's almost impossible for us on this side of the fence to fathom the spam problem from the search engines' side of the fence.
Suffice it to say that spam is a major issue with the search engines in terms of time, resources, and ultimately money. New filters are added by the engines to combat spam, and the Web community finds new ways to cheat their way to the top. Algorithms are changed, and sites get banned. Webmasters scream about how unfair it is, and the saga continues.
Let's STOP the Nonsense!
Is it fair to complain about "injustices": being banned; the sandbox; supplemental index; etc., if your site was banned or penalized for not following the engine's guidelines?
Google, in particular, has clearly stated that it wants content of value to the Web audience, natural link building, no spam, and other quite logical Webmaster guidelines.
http://www.google.com/intl/en/webmasters/guidelines.html
Take a Walk in Google's Shoes
Your "Role": Honorary Google Editors
Let's take a walk in Google's shoes. What would it be like to be an editor of a search engine? What would it be like to have to deal with spam from their side of the fence?
How lenient should you be? At what point would your patience wear out? Would you make exceptions to the rules? Why, and when?
Remember: You've posted spam and Webmaster guidelines on the Internet, but the guidelines are continually ignored. The envelope is being pushed to the limits.
As a search engine, you want your SERPS to be relevant. If they're not relevant, you lose your market share.
Our Research
We conducted some research in this area by putting on some editor shoes. It was an amazing learning experience.
One of the keyword phrases we chose was Viagra. We wanted a highly competitive keyword phrase in terms of the number of searches performed on a daily basis, the number of competing pages, and the likelihood of a high number of SEOs who are actually competing for the phrase. This keyword met the criteria.
At the time of our research, there were 47,800,000 competing pages in Google, with a 24-hour potential for traffic in Google (using Wordtracker numbers) of 3811. The popularity figure for the keyword across all of the major engines is 6226 (over a 90- day period across all the engines that Wordtracker gets its data from).
The site we chose was actually #10 out of the top 10 results, but it's no longer in that position (more details to follow).
More About the Site
The site was a one-page sales letter with content coming straight from the manufacturer. I found 572 other sites on the Web that were using the same exact sales copy.
The keyword was being used 56 times in the visible body text. In other words, the keyword density was way over a reasonable number.
There were no inbound links whatsoever. None at least none that were recognized by Google.
So, what do we have? Keyword overuse, duplicate content, and no off-page factors.
However, the site actually read well. From a user experience, if they put "viagra" in the search box, they would land on a page that sold the product. It didn't look or sound spammy in any way. It was written by the manufacturer as a sales letter.
You have to assume that some people who put "viagra" into the search box are looking to buy the product. If they clicked on this site, their query would match their expectations.
How did this Page Get in the Top Results?
It's important to note that the page slipped to #35 within a few days after we found it at #10, and within a week, it slipped out of the top 100 listings. So, its rankings didn't last.
When you optimize pages, don't you want your rankings to last to stand the test of time? You should!
There's a reason this page landed on the first page of results, but the reason is immaterial. The trick didn't work, plus by mentioning it here, I'd be opening the door for people to abuse it to try to get top rankings. Again, the reason doesn't matter. It didn't work.
Looking at the Current Top 10 Results
In studying the top 10 SERPS at the time of this writing, Google is showing a wide variety of results. The first two results are the main Viagra.com site. Very appropriate.
The next two results are the FDA.com site. Again, very appropriate. All of these sites are informational sites about the product.
Other sites are devoted to real people's experiences, other medical-related sites, risks related to the pill, etc. Some of these sites may have places where you can order the medication, but they're more informational sites.
Of course, Google AdWords offer sites where you can purchase the medication.
So, you can see how truly relevant the top 10 results are. This is a very important point to understand.
What Else did We Learn?
Spam is in the "eyes" of the editor. We found a site that actually read well and would serve up relevant results to the end user.
Yet, it was using what I consider to be "spam" strategies. They were overusing their keyword phrase. They were using duplicate content used by hundreds of other Web sites.
However, is this the same as using AP copy across the Net for news-related sites?
The site was of low quality, but does that make it spam?
The Webmaster guidelines don't say anything about low quality Web sites. In fact, Google's Webmaster guidelines say this:
"Avoid tricks intended to improve search engine rankings. A good rule of thumb is whether you'd feel comfortable explaining what you've done to a website that competes with you. Another useful test is to ask, 'Does this help my users? Would I do this if search engines didn't exist?'"
This Web site was simply using promotional material to promote their product. It helped the end user by selling the product they were searching for. Yes, the promotional material "overused" the keyword phrase and had been used all over the Web.
This site proves that spam is subjective, and Google editors really have their hands full. It's much harder than it looks.
In Conclusion
Though we all know what constitutes spam, spam is subjective in many cases. It's not all "black and white."
Matt Cutts discussed on his blog how innocent Web site owners often use strategies and don't realize they're spam. Google takes a different approach to those type of "spammers," versus the more sophisticated spammers who are trying to trick and cheat.
http://www.mattcutts.com/blog/notifying-webmasters-of-penalties
So, spend some time walking in the search engine's shoes. Think about the sheer amount of spam they get, and how they have to protect their engine from it. Make sure your own sites are playing it straight, and you'll be helping us all.
About the Author:
Robin Nobles conducts live SEO workshops in locations across North America. She also teaches online SEO training. Localized SEO training is now being offered through the Search Engine Academy. Sign up for SEO tips of the day at seo-tip@aweber.com.
|
